This comprehensive yet accessible comparison of website builders, Content Management Systems (CMS) and Digital Experience Platforms (DXP) cuts through technical complexity to demonstrate how solutions like Squiz and others can assist your organization in implementing secure user portals, automating documentation, and enhancing your digital visibility—while safeguarding sensitive information in an increasingly hostile online environment.

The best part? You won't need technical expertise to grasp the advantages and limitations of each option.

Skip ahead:

• Categories of Website Platforms for Businesses
  • What is a Traditional CMS platform?
  • What is a Headless CMS Platform?
  • What is a Digital Experience Platform (DXP)?
• Top Traditional CMS Platforms
  • Typical Traditional CMS Platforms are known for
  • Challenges
  • Optimal match for
• Top Headless CMS Platforms
  • Typical Headless CMS Platforms are known for
  • Challenges
  • Optimal match for
• Top legacy Digital Experience Platforms (DXPs)
  • Typical legacy DXPs are known for
  • Challenges
  • Optimal match for
• The Digital Experience Platform for Intelligent Experiences: Squiz
  • Advantages of Squiz
  • The challenges with Squiz
  • Optimal match for
• How to select the right CMS or DXP
• Free Migration Offer

To eliminate confusion, we'll begin by explaining the fundamental differences between each platform category below. Then, we'll examine the strengths and weaknesses of each.

Conventional CMSs powered many initial corporate websites and still capably host fundamental content like staff profiles and product information. However, they operate merely as content repositories – not the comprehensive digital solutions required by contemporary organizations.

Companies quickly encounter restrictions when attempting to implement essential features like process automation, protected customer portals, or enterprise system connections. When your commercial team needs to monitor prospect journeys from initial research to consultation requests, or your service division aims to provide customer-specific information access, these platforms frequently necessitate expensive custom development.

Most also trail in AI implementation, providing minimal automation or content discovery features that today's competitive enterprises utilize to showcase value to discerning customers.

Headless solutions separate the "body" of a content management system (the backend) from the "head" (the frontend). For enterprises, this means your success stories, product specifications, and personnel profiles can be stored centrally but displayed universally – from your website to customer portals, mobile applications, and even reception area displays.

Technology teams value their adaptability when constructing specialized tools like custom intake workflows that differ by service category. Marketing departments, however, typically discover they have reduced control over design modifications. When your organization needs to rapidly launch a new landing page for an emerging trend or refresh team credentials across all platforms, you'll generally depend on developers, potentially postponing time-sensitive content about industry shifts or competitive offerings.

While headless architecture delivers superior technical possibilities, organizations without dedicated development resources may experience increased operational expenses and delayed marketing response times, particularly during crises or competitive market expansions.

DXPs evolved to address organizations' requirements beyond basic website content administration. They're engineered to customize user journeys, execute A/B testing on conversion forms, incorporate AI for highly-relevant content discovery, and integrate effortlessly with critical systems like CRM and ERP platforms—all from a single secure environment.

While conventional DXPs offer extensive capabilities, they frequently require businesses to embrace their complete ecosystem. Modern "composable" DXPs deliver greater flexibility, allowing your company to choose specific functionalities while maintaining compatibility with specialized business tools you've previously implemented. This becomes particularly significant when connecting business systems or customer-specific secure portals.

User-friendliness varies dramatically between platforms, directly influencing adoption by streamlined Digital Marketing and Business Development teams—a crucial factor we'll explore in our comparisons.

Now, let's examine how specific vendors measure up against the actual requirements of modern enterprises.

Or, navigate directly to the category or vendors you're most interested in:

Traditional content management systems have long been the backbone of enterprise web presence, offering proven solutions for organizations seeking established, community-supported platforms. These systems typically feature open-source architectures with extensive customization capabilities, making them popular choices for businesses prioritizing flexibility and control over their digital infrastructure.

Security capabilities: Offer formidable security capabilities, including database encryption, though that advantage depends on diligent maintenance of modules and integrations. They provide strong management of user permissions and workflows—vital when executives, managers, and marketing require varying access levels.

Vast customization possibilities: With numerous modules, themes and plugins. Organizations benefit from extensive libraries to get started, and enable significant modification options without being constrained by some proprietary platform limitations.

Vibrant development communities: Strong developer communities that know how to build on these platforms, though ongoing availability of the highly specialized skills are needed to maintain the websites effectively.

Economical implementation: These platforms can be more affordable for initial setup due to their open-source nature.

Available developer talent: Readily available content administrators familiar with the platform, minimizing training expenses.

Technical Complexity & Developer Dependency: Staff struggle with these platforms' complex interfaces—these aren't platforms marketing or content teams can rapidly master for content updates. Even straightforward updates typically demand developer assistance, creating technical bottlenecks during urgent situations. This dependency results in slow speed-to-market for campaigns and initiatives, while the lack of agility hampers the performance and impact of marketing and digital teams, who cannot respond quickly to market opportunities or competitive pressures.

Security maintenance requirements: Security patches – essential for data protection – transform into mini-projects requiring methodical planning and evaluation, taxing already stretched IT departments. Protection requires consistent updates and fortification to safeguard confidential customer information and sensitive details.

Performance and scalability limitations:  As organizations grow and incorporate additional modules, plugins, and business system integrations, traditional CMS platforms frequently experience performance degradation. The typical explosion of third-party extensions and plugins used can create conflicts and slow page load times – critical factors affecting user experience and SEO or AI-search visibility in today's competitive environment.

Escalating Total Cost of Ownership: Though initially budget-friendly, enterprise-grade security, speed optimization, and specialized developer assistance substantially increase Total Cost of Ownership. While these platforms remain open-source, the specialized proficiency to support them is increasingly costly, especially when competing against other sectors for scarce technical expertise.

Limited approval workflows: Restricted native approval procedures are insufficient for organizations requiring multi-tier review of published material, creating operational gaps in content governance and quality control.

Governance and brand consistency challenges: Multi-location, multi-division organizations (with many content editors) struggle to enforce consistent branding standards and content governance. Limited native approval workflows prove insufficient where multi-tier content review processes are required, potentially exposing organizations to compliance risks and brand inconsistencies.

Large organizations with substantial in-house development capabilities seeking maximum control over their digital infrastructure, possessing dedicated resources to maintain and evolve the platform continuously.

Headless content management systems (CMS) have emerged as a modern approach to content delivery, separating content creation from presentation layers. API-first platforms promise omnichannel content distribution and developer-friendly architectures, appealing to technology-forward organizations seeking flexible content solutions across multiple digital touchpoints.

Omnichannel content distribution: Headless platforms excel at enabling profiles and resources to appear consistently across websites, mobile apps, and portals from a single source. This approach maintains consistent presentation across all devices and platforms, reinforcing your brand's professional image while eliminating content duplication across channels.

API-first developer resources: The API-first developer resources facilitate custom integrations and powerful API capabilities for effortless connections to other systems. The API-adaptability enables smooth integration with business-specific applications, though significant custom development is often necessary as pre-built components are minimal.

Content structure enforcement: Headless CMS platforms enforce content structures, ensuring uniform formatting of documents and updates across channels. This includes authority over your configuration with custom content models for specific business segments, and specializations without platform constraints.

Flexible access management and collaboration: Headless CMSs offer role-specific access management for overseeing content across different departments, along with live collaboration features for distributed content teams. An adaptable content studio conforms to your organization's processes, with security including role-specific access control and GDPR compliance.

Open-source foundation benefits: Many headless platforms provide robust open-source foundations with access to extensive developer networks. Zero licensing fees for standard versions offer initial cost advantages, though paid enterprise editions are typically necessary for the security and support most businesses demand.

Technical complexity and steep learning curves: Headless platforms require considerable technical proficiency to implement and administer effectively. The adoption curve is steeper than typical visual WISYWIG editors, particularly for non-technical content creators.

Developer dependency and speed-to-market impact
The decoupled architecture of headless CMSs is complex, making real-time previews and inline editing less common. Marketers then rely on developers for changes such as new landing page templates or personalized content setups, reducing marketing agility and increasing time-to-market. But some platforms are starting to make advances in API design, frontend integration, and CMS tooling to close the gap.

Limited ready-to-use templates and industry solutions: Headless platforms don't tend to offer ready-to-use industry-specific templates for product categories, team profiles, or success stories – requiring custom construction. The absence of pre-configured industry content templates means organizations must invest heavily in custom development.

Escalating costs and budget uncertainties: Expenses can multiply as your content and utilization expand, with costs increasing based on content volume and API requests, creating budget uncertainties as your resource library grows. Costs can escalate rapidly for larger implementations with numerous users. Cost creep often occurs for unpredictable development, support, security customization, and upkeep, making the total investment significantly higher than initial projections.

Implementation and maintenance challenges: Self-reliant implementation and ongoing maintenance present challenges for organizations lacking dedicated developers. Free editions lack the enterprise-grade support essential when storing sensitive customer information or time-critical content, forcing organizations toward more costly enterprise solutions to meet core needs.

Tech-forward organizations with dedicated development assets. Ideal for organizations with substantial development resources requiring highly specialized content models who prioritize complete control over their digital ecosystem and are willing to invest in building tailored digital infrastructure.

Large, legacy Digital Experience Platforms represent the enterprise-grade evolution of content management, combining content delivery with advanced personalization, analytics, and marketing automation capabilities. These comprehensive solutions target large organizations requiring sophisticated digital experiences across multiple touchpoints, though they come with corresponding complexity and investment requirements.

Advanced personalization and customer targeting: DXPs excel at sophisticated customization to target content according to customer profiles and behavior, with effective personalization that adapts content based on customer interactions. These platforms enable organizations to deliver tailored experiences to drive engagement and conversion across complex journeys.

Comprehensive analytics and marketing integration: They provide comprehensive analytics tracking user interactions with your site and content, along with integrated marketing tools that track engagement and automate content delivery. This data-driven approach enables organizations to optimize content performance and marketing effectiveness across all digital channels.

Enterprise-scale content and asset management
DXPs offer extensive digital asset management for your organization's expanding content collection, efficiently managing extensive content volumes and heavy traffic loads. They provide productive multi-site capabilities for organizations managing multiple locations or business divisions, ensuring consistent brand experiences at scale.

Enterprise-level Security and system integration: These platforms deliver comprehensive enterprise-level security and compliance features critical for confidential information, along with smooth integration capabilities with existing enterprise tools and systems when properly implemented.

Significant financial investment requirements: Organizations must prepare for significant financial investments with substantial licensing fees plus extensive implementation and maintenance support – both initial and ongoing. These platforms rank among the priciest options available, with significant licensing, implementation, and ongoing maintenance expenses that may exceed requirements for all but the largest organizations.

Complex implementation and organizational impact: Implementation can be complex – it's a major organizational undertaking requiring thorough planning, resources, and typically external consultation. The platform complexity demands substantial IT resources for implementation and ongoing maintenance, when often more right-sized, easy-to-adopt solutions could drive better outcomes.

Specialized skills and training requirements: Personnel require extensive instruction to utilize even core features, creating potential adoption obstacles and ROI inefficiencies. These platforms necessitate specialized developers and administrators who are expensive to recruit and retain, creating ongoing staffing challenges and budget pressures that hold back team agility.

Feature overengineering and integration limitations: Many organizations pay for capabilities they don't need, with features that exceed the requirements of most businesses. Broad-based DXPs often lack specialized industry functionality addressing unique business marketing and development requirements, while presenting difficulties with connections to industry-specific systems.

Resource-intensive maintenance: The complexity of these platforms creates ongoing maintenance burdens that tax IT teams and require continuous specialized support, limiting flexibility and responsiveness to changing market conditions.

Global, well-resourced organizations with highly intricate digital requirements and substantial budgets. Ideal for large, multinational organizations with dedicated technical teams, substantial budgets, and ongoing resources for maintenance. Perfect for businesses with sophisticated personalization use cases and content capabilities across extensive product categories, though excessive for simpler organizational needs.

Squiz DXP is a DXP trusted by enterprise organizations preparing for an AI-first world. As one of the few Gartner-ranked Digital Experience Platforms in the market, Squiz distinguishes itself with many advantages.

Exceptional adaptability and customization: Exceptional adaptability and customization for different business segments, with significant experience serving the Higher Education, Government, Professional Services, Financial Services and Utilities sectors.

User-friendly, low-code tools: An easy-to-use, low-code visual page builder and Gen-AI for content editing and governance – Marketing and staff can generate content, design pages, personalize and conduct tests quickly – eliminating developer dependence.

High-precision enterprise search: A high-precision enterprise search tool (powered by Funnelback) that offers a low-code, easily configurable search tuning – indexing content from any source and format – such as documents, success stories, and web content.

Conversational AI search capability: A Conversational AI Search capability – offering a Chat-GPT like experience on your site, using only approved web content to offer answers, not just results links.

Performance optimization tools: Powerful, yet intuitive personalization, AB testing and user journey mapping tools to optimize performance.

Enterprise governance controls: Sophisticated governance controls with detailed role-based permissions and approval workflows.

Flexible architecture: A hybrid architecture (headless and head-on) offering organizations publishing flexibility and scalability.

Robust integrations platform: Robust integrations platform to seamlessly connect your existing Martech, CRM and other core applications.

High-capacity infrastructure: Substantial content volume and traffic handling, to support organizations with extensive information repositories.

Enterprise-grade security: Enterprise-grade security and compliance safeguards protecting sensitive information and customer data with Cloudflare and AWS infrastructure.

Superior performance: Deployment at the edge, for superior performance and user experience.

Cost-effective solution: More cost-efficient and predictable than most enterprise platforms – transparent pricing based on usage metrics.

Misconceptions about technical requirements: Some presume technical expertise is required – this misconception persists despite their focus on user-friendliness, alongside advanced enterprise-grade capabilities.

Template availability: Fewer ready-made templates than niche industry providers.

Market presence in certain sectors: Less established in certain sectors than legacy systems – though 14 years of Gartner Quadrant recognition affirms its enterprise credentials.

Planning requirements: Initial configuration involves careful planning to maximize ongoing independence from IT – readily supported by Squiz project experts or through their extensive partner network.

Forward-looking, mid-to-large-sized organizations requiring secure and sophisticated digital experiences without sacrificing speed. Ideal for Marketing teams driving performance, without developer reliance. With Squiz, organizations can rapidly deliver personalized user experiences and continually optimize them leveraging powerful, yet low-code tools and built-in AI capabilities.

Your website platform influences every aspect of your organization's digital operations, and the difference between selecting the appropriate and inappropriate platform can be substantial. One empowers your marketing and business development team to drive growth, while the other constrains you in endless cycles of IT tickets, slow updates, or increasing costs.

Let's simplify the decision-making process to find what works best for your organization:

For Large, Multi-Division Organizations

If you're managing multiple business areas and require significant customization and integration capabilities, consider:

• Squiz for enterprise capabilities without compromising usability and responsiveness
• Traditional CMS platforms if you possess extensive technical resources and desire comprehensive customization
• Digital Experience Platforms if financial constraints aren't an issue and you require a sophisticated enterprise system (and you're committed to the Adobe ecosystem)

For Specialized and Mid-Size Organizations

Working with more focused requirements? Examine:

• Traditional CMS platforms for simple, cost-effective basic content administration
• Squiz for enterprise features without enterprise complexity and expense
• Headless Platforms if you maintain substantial technical resources and require multi-channel content distribution

For Advanced Tech-Forward Organizations

Have strong technical capabilities and want increased flexibility? Consider:

• Any Headless CMS Platform or building custom solutions
• Traditional CMS Platform if you prefer a developer-oriented CMS with extensive customization options
• Squiz if you need both technical adaptability and marketing autonomy to deliver results quickly

For Marketing-Focused Teams

Need to operate efficiently and create exceptional experiences without constant IT assistance?

• Traditional CMS platforms for basic content management needs with minimal technical requirements
• Digital Experience Platforms if you're already utilizing Adobe tools, have advanced use cases and possess the budget to support it
• Squiz delivers personalization, testing, search and AI capabilities without technical overhead

Evaluating your options can take time, and there’s always a cost consideration. We’d like to help remove cost and migration headaches from the equation and give you access to Squiz DXP quickly. So much so, that we’ll migrate you for free. for a limited time. Find out more about the offer.

Need help prioritizing your needs?

Require a RFP template?